Movie Review:
Ghost Stories (2017)
A Masterclass in Terror: Why Ghost Stories is a Modern Horror Classic:
Every so often, a horror film comes along that doesn't just scare you—it unsettles you to your very core, lingering in the dark corners of your mind long after the credits roll.
The 2017 adaptation of Ghost Stories, written and directed by Jeremy Dyson and Andy Nyman, is precisely that kind of masterpiece. It is a love letter to the British horror anthologies of the past, yet it stands entirely on its own as a sophisticated, psychologically complex, and truly terrifying piece of cinema.
A Storyline of Unparalleled Depth:
At first glance, Ghost Stories appears to be a traditional portmanteau film, but to view it only as such is to miss its genius. The narrative follows Professor Phillip Goodman, a professional skeptic and debunker of the supernatural. His world is one of logic and reason until he is challenged to solve three inexplicable "cold cases" that threaten to shatter his reality.
What makes the storyline so exceptional is its architectural precision. This isn't just a collection of scary moments; it is a puzzle box. The transition between the three vignettes—a lonely night watchman, a paranoid teenager, and a wealthy financier—is seamless, weaving a tapestry of guilt, trauma, and existential dread. The script respects the audience's intelligence, offering clues that only click into place during the film’s shattering conclusion. It balances genuine jump-scares with a suffocating atmosphere of dread that is rare in modern horror.
A Cast That Elevates the Genre:
The film's emotional weight rests entirely on its four central performances, all of which are nothing short of spectacular:
* Andy Nyman (Professor Goodman): Reprising his role from the stage play, Nyman is the perfect anchor for this descent into madness. He plays Goodman with a fascinating mix of arrogance and vulnerability. As the film progresses, watching his stoic facade crumble is a masterclass in subtle acting. He makes us care deeply about a man who spends his life telling others they are wrong.
* Paul Whitehouse (Tony Matthews): Known primarily for comedy, Whitehouse delivers a revelation of a performance. As the night watchman in the film's first story, he is heartbreakingly authentic. He captures the essence of a man hollowed out by loneliness and guilt, bringing a grounded, tragic humanity to a terrifying supernatural encounter.
* Alex Lawther (Simon Rifkind): Lawther is electric. In the second story, he plays a teenager tormented by a demonic encounter in the woods. His performance is a jittery, wide-eyed display of pure paranoia. He manages to be both deeply sympathetic and utterly unnerving, physically embodying the concept of fear.
* Martin Freeman (Mike Priddle): Freeman is superb as the polished, wealthy financier of the third story. He utilizes his natural affability to disarm the viewer, only to twist it into something cold and menacing. His delivery is razor-sharp, shifting from casual conversation to terrifying intensity in the blink of an eye.
The Sonic Landscape: Frank Ilfman’s Magnificent Score:
No horror film can succeed without the right auditory atmosphere, and the music score composed by Frank Ilfman is, simply put, magnificent.
Ilfman shuns the generic "droning" sounds of modern thrillers in favor of a rich, orchestral score that harkens back to the glory days of Hammer Horror. It is elegant yet oppressive, using strings and brass to build a sense of impending doom. The music becomes a character in itself, knowing exactly when to swell to a crescendo and, more importantly, when to fall silent. It wraps the film in a gothic texture that elevates the production value to a cinematic art form.
The Brilliant Ending:
To spoil the ending of Ghost Stories would be a crime, but it must be praised. The finale is a stroke of narrative brilliance that recontextualizes everything that came before it. It moves beyond simple "twists" and delves into profound psychological territory.
The conclusion is not just shocking; it is emotionally resonant. It ties the three seemingly disparate stories together with a logic that is both heartbreaking and horrifying. It forces the audience to re-examine the clues they missed, turning the film from a ghost story into a tragedy about the human mind. It is a finale that demands an immediate re-watch.
The Verdict:
Ghost Stories is a triumph. With Andy Nyman’s guiding hand, career-best performances from Whitehouse, Lawther, and Freeman, and Frank Ilfman’s haunting score, it is a perfect storm of filmmaking. It is witty, terrifying, and deeply moving—a modern classic that proves the most haunting ghosts are the ones we carry with us.
Review by Emily Faulkner.